Returns to Education in Russia (News and Research 217)
Harry A. Patrinos and Suhas Parandekar
Wisdom.. comes not from age but from education and learning – Anton Chekov
Because of a strong literary tradition and a deep commitment to education, Russia had a highly educated population by the end of the 20th century. Today, nearly two-thirds of 25 to 34 year olds have completed post-secondary studies, along with just over half of 55 to 64-year-olds, well above the OECD averages. In terms of learning achievement, the picture is a bit less flattering. Russia’s 4th grade students are ranked highest on PISA for reading, but by the 8th or 9th grade, Russia is ranked about the same as the OECD average and lower when collaborative problem-solving skills are taken into account. Nevertheless, Russia can still be regarded as one of the most educated nations in the world.
Higher education levels usually translate into higher productivity and higher earnings. However, Sofia Cheidvasser and Hugo Benítez-Silva found very low returns to education in Russia in the 1990s, only about 5 percent (compared to the global average of 9 percent), even at a time when the market in Russia was opening up. If an education added such little value in terms of wages at that time, they posited that this might have given educated Russians a reason to emigrate.
The World Bank 2019 report How Wealthy Is Russia? found that human capital accounts for only 46 percent of Russia’s total wealth compared with an OECD average of 70 percent. Average per capita human capital wealth in 2014 was about US$500,000 for the OECD, five times higher than in Russia. Although per capita wealth was growing 10 times faster in Russia than in the OECD, the gap in the relative levels of wealth was still very wide.
Were there really very low returns to education in post-Soviet Russia?
In our new working paper, Returns to Education in the Russian Federation: Some New Estimates, with Ekaterina Melianova and Artëm Volgin, we examined returns to education in the Russian Federation between 1994 and 2018 using data from the Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey (RLMS). We found that:
- Average years of schooling increased from 12.4 to 13.3 years, and the proportion of the labor force with a higher education increased from 26 to 41 percent.
- Returns to schooling increased from 7 percent in 1994 to 9.1 percent in 2001. However, returns averaged only 6.3 percent between 2008 and 2018, which was among the lowest worldwide, and by 2018, they had fallen to 5.4 percent.
- Returns to higher education peaked at 18 percent in 1998, but by 2018 they had settled at 8 percent, which is just below the European Union average of 10 percent and well below the global average of 15 percent. However, these returns were three times higher than for vocational education (2 percent).
- Returns to education for females were much higher than for males during the first few years of the new century, averaging above 10 percent. While they subsequently declined, they are still significantly higher than those for men.
The returns peaked in the early 2000s (at almost 10 percent) followed by a downward pattern (returns of 5.6 percent by 2018). The returns to schooling in Russia are now much lower than the global average. On average, an additional year of education yields only a small – and declining – increase in wages. More than one-third of the labor force possesses a post-secondary qualification. The extent to which the declines are due to potential “over-education” is worth investigating. In this regard, higher education may have reached an expansion limit causing a decline in educational premiums. But private returns to education are three times greater for higher education compared to vocational education. It could be that vocational schooling is reducing the overall return to schooling. Thus, there is a need to investigate the labor market relevance of vocational education. Female education continues to benefit from being a government priority. Future research could also look at the variations in returns across regions. Also, recent school closures and the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic will reduce the earnings of all current students once they reach the labor market, though higher education graduates can be expected to suffer the least. Because of these declining returns, it may be necessary to explore ways to increase the productivity of schooling at all levels.
This blog first appeared on the World Bank’s Education for Global Development blog: https://blogs.worldbank.org/education/educated-russians-curse-returns-education-russian-federation-1990s
Thinking critically about critical thinking: validating the Russian HEIghten® critical thinking assessment Critical thinking has been identified as a crucial general skill contributing to academic and career success in the twenty-first century. With the increasing demands of the modern
workplace and a global trend of accountability in higher education, educators and …
Schooling and Covid-19: lessons from recent research on EdTech | The wide-scale global movement of school education to remote instruction due to Covid-19 is unprecedented. The use of educational technology (EdTech) offers an alternative to in-person learning and reinforces social distancing, but there is limited evidence on whether and how EdTech affects academic outcomes. Recently, we conducted two large-scale randomized experiments, involving ~10,000 primary school students in China and Russia, to evaluate the effectiveness of EdTech as a substitute for traditional schooling. In China, we examined whether EdTech improves academic outcomes relative to paper-and-pencil workbook exercises of identical content. We found that EdTech was a perfect substitute for traditional learning. In Russia, we further explored how much EdTech can substitute for traditional learning. We found that EdTech substitutes only to a limited extent. The findings from these large-scale trials indicate that we need to be careful about using EdTech as a full-scale substitute for the traditional instruction received by schoolchildren.
Coronavirus: students to replace older teachers in Moscow | Trainees and graduates will teach in primary schools amid record infections in Russia
Russia World Bank assessment of the impact of the pandemic and distance learning on the lifetime earnings of children was picked up by all major media outlets with featured stories: The World Bank assesses the losses of Russian schoolchildren due to quarantine (Vedomosti.ru): “During the coronavirus pandemic, Russian schoolchildren lost more than a third of their academic year, which in the future may lead to a deterioration in their results in the PISA test (an international program for assessing student educational achievement) and a decrease in earnings when schoolchildren become adults, according to the World Bank’s report “COVID- 19 and human…” Всемирный банк оценил потери российских школьников из-за карантина (Vedomosti.ru) | Российские школьники в период пандемии коронавируса потеряли более трети учебного года, что в будущем может привести к ухудшению их результатов в тесте PISA (международной программе по оценке образовательных достижений учащихся) и снижению заработка, когда школьники станут взрослыми, говорится в докладе Всемирного банка «COVID-19 и человеческий ка
Зарплата пропускает школьные уроки (Kommersant.ru)
Всемирный банк: школьники потеряют 2,5% доходов из-за пропущенных во время карантина уроков (Kommersant.ru)
В докладе Всемирного банка говорится, что российские школьники в период пандемии потеряли более трети учебного года (Echo Moskvy Independent Radio)
ВБ: закрытие школ снизит доходы российских выпускников и социальный статус (Vesti.ru)
Рассчитана потеря будущего заработка российских детей из-за дистанционки (MK.RU)
Всемирный банк спрогнозировал, как карантин в российских школах скажется на будущем заработке учеников (Snob.ru)
COVID-19: страшные последствия для российских школьников (Rambler.ru)
ЭКОНОМИКА Всемирный банк назвал последствия от потери учебного времени школьниками РФ (Izvestia)
Всемирный банк оценил потери учеников от карантина в российских школах (RBC)
Всемирный банк объявил о потерях российских школьников из-за карантина (News24)
Дистанционка — шаг к бедности? Станут ли наши дети зарабатывать меньше (AIF.ru)
ВСЕМИРНЫЙ БАНК: ШКОЛЬНИКИ ТЕРЯЮТ 2,5% БУДУЩИХ ДОХОДОВ ИЗ-ЗА КАРАНТИНА (runews24.ru)
Всемирный банк подсчитал потери российских школьников из-за пандемии (Мир новостей)
Ковидное поколение: почему “удаленка” в школах – приговор российским детям (anews.com)
Всемирный банк подсчитал потери российских школьников из-за пандемии (360tv.ru)
В Госдуме оценили прогноз Всемирного банка о снижении будущих доходов школьников (daily storm)
This is a product of our RAS in KMAO region of Russia. Детский сад-трансформер в Белоярском будет готов к октябрю. Строящийся объект во время рабочего визита в муниципалитет посетили глава минстроя Владимир Якушев и губернатор Югры Наталья Комарова. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_SLUOMjqIg
How digital transformation is improving education in Georgia | Source | October 17 marks World Poverty Day. The World Bank Georgia Office has devoted a special video clip to this occasion, which was released today on the World Bank social media and official online pages. A video clip tells about how the World Bank is helping Georgia’s poverty alleviation with various ongoing projects, including the Log-in Georgia and Innovation, Inclusion and Quality (I2Q) Project. The main character of the video is Inga Khvedelidze, an elementary school teacher from the mountainous village of Argokhi, who shares her experience on the importance of the internet and access to digital technologies to improve the quality of education, especially during a pandemic. 1000 villages will be connected to high-quality internet within the framework of the World Bank support for the digital transformation of Georgia (Log-in Georgia Project). The World Bank is supporting the development of human capital in Georgia through an education quality improvement project (Innovation, Inclusion and Quality (I2Q).
Does closing schools close doors? Important new research shows that learning losses take time to recover. Timely, given that COVID-19 school closures showing us for some youth time is running out.